Forum

England's selection has been pretty dire this tournament. Not so much with the first XI, which I largely agreed with, but with the squad players. When things started to go wrong we had no-one to replace misfiring Jimmy and Colly, and we were eventually desperate enough to play Luke Wright. And worse, rely on him.

Need to go:

> Mike Yardy. Time up, I'm afraid. They were playing him as long as they could get away with it.

> Luke Wright. You know why.

> Paul Collingwood. He's not timing a thing any more. This is an undignified end for England's most accomplished ODI cricketer.

> James Tredwell. I don't hate him. I'd quite like him if he were, say, my uncle or milkman. Far from the second best spinner in the country.

> Matt Prior. Too restricted technically and not enough to his game for ODIs. Aggresive does not mean fast scoring when you can only score square on the off side.

> Ian Bell. Bell makes a lot of sense when he's in touch, stroking fours and looking good, hence why I had no issue with him in the side at the start. Now, that just isn't the case and he's only serving to waste time while more versatile batsman can at least get singles and rotate.

Coming in:

> Steve Davies. Can actually keep, and is one of the best LO openers in the country. Two birds, one stone.

> James Hildreth. The form middle-order batsman. May not be a permenant solution but he's there right now. KP, once he returns from injury, will need to earn his place back.

I also think we need to pick 5 proper bowlers, Bresnan and Swann are good enough at 7 and 8, especially with Broad/Woakes/Shahzad as back up. Jimmy will be back when he gets his head sorted out. Bopara is a support bowler only.

XI for this summer:

Strauss, Davies, Trott, Hildreth, Bopara, Morgan, Bresnan, Swann, Broad, Woakes, Shahzad.

I think Rashid and Cook definitely need considering and I certainly wouldn't chuck out Ian Bell, otherwise I generally agree with you Howe_zat.

@Daveemrys: I really think you must keep Strauss in, he does tend to be too conservative too often in the field but the Flower-Strauss team is far too good to break up, Strauss is too successful a batsman and Cook shouldn't be captaining an ODI team he hasn't been in so far and still may not be suited to. Samit Patel, unless he's massively turned around his attitude with training etc. is a poor choice to have in the team, its a real pity because he can be good but unless he changes you can't have him in. Also I suspect Hildreth is given his chance before Taylor. A change back to Davies or to Kieswetter seems sensible if Davies can find form. Prior is serviceable though if you could keep him down at 6 or 7 but as you say he isn't technically capable enough to open.

Lubidog,

I'm also from Hinckley and Despite Wright's performance against the Windies can find no logical reason as to his continued inclusion in the squad let alone team. He may have played for our local side, but there again so did Omari Banks.

The point of my blog was about building a side for the next world cup, which is why I have omitted strauss. As I don't realistically think he will still be playing ODI's in four years time.